Many research articles are written on ethical leadership which leads to better
corporate governance practices, but the concept of wholesome leadership is new. Before we proceed
on this subject, let us examine what ethics and ethical leadership means. Thereafter, the issue
of wholesome leadership will be dealt with.
Donaldson and Dunfee (1994 and 1995) proposed the Integrated Social Contract Theory
(ISCT) which was an informal agreement concerning behavioral norms developed from shared
goals, beliefs and attitudes of groups of people or communities. Donaldson held that
`business organizations gain legitimacy through a social contract theory with the society'. According
to him, a productive organization is one that ensures customer satisfaction and protects
the interests of its workers, thereby enhancing the welfare of the society and
business. Donaldson (1982) argued that social contracts can be used as a tool to measure
the performance of a productive organization. If the organization fulfills the terms of the
contracts, it has performed well. This as per the European model, is the essence of corporate
governance systems. If the contracts are not fulfilled, then the society is justified in condemning
the organization. The main elements of the social contracts are hypernorms, like human
rights, physical security, personal freedom, right to own property, etc. Secondly, macro social
contracts like `moral free space' must be based on free will of all parties involved, all of whom have
right to exit when they please. However, Strong and Ringer (2000) argued that it must be
compatible with hypernorms. Finally, micro social contract means norms developed by a community,
a group either economic or social. For example, an industry, a company or a
non-profit organization are all communities. As stated earlier, in the case of conflict of macro
social contract with hypernorms, the latter will prevail. Donaldson and Dundee (1994 and
1995) further stated that in case a community decides to do business with another community,
the norms of the host community shall prevail and be the guiding factor. Husted (1999) added
that the more extensive or global the community is, the greater will be the priority given to
its norms. The norms that are helpful to preserve the economic environment will have priority
over the norms that damage the economic environment. |