The Structure Conduct Performance (SCP) Model is an effective tool for
industry analysis. The objective of this study is to analyze the Indian Steel
Industry with respect to the SCP model and find out the parameters, which
significantly affect its structure, conduct and performance over a period of
14 years across the industry. Regression Analysis is used as a tool to extract
the above information. The study attempts to combine industry level
aggregate data with firm level information from the CMIE (Centre for
Monitoring Indian Economy) database to test specified hypothesis. The paper
concludes that in order to obtain higher profitability in the Indian Steel
Industry, firms must either lower their cost of production and/or government
regulation must decrease.
The analysis of the industry has for long been the subject for discussion for both academicians
and practitioners. The seminal work on industry analysis was done by Mason [11] where he
argued that the structure of an industry would determine the conduct of buyers and sellers which
in turn would determine the performance of the industry. The performance of the industry could
be measured by profitability, innovativeness or efficiency. Bain [4] advanced the research work
by empirically proving that profit margin in manufacturing industries in which eight large
competitors accounted for more than 70% of the sales were nearly twice that of industries in
which eight firm Concentration Ratios was less that 70% (Concentration Ratio is the summation
of the top firms in an industry divided by the total sales in the industry). Bain’s [4] insight led
to the growth of a new sub-field of economics known as ‘Industrial Organization’ or IO in short
[7]. The next big break came in 1980 when Michael E Porter [12] launched his landmark book
‘Competitive Strategy’ where he described the widely used Porter’s Five Forces Model. In mid-
1990s, two strategies Adam Brandenburger and Barry Nalebuff [3] brought in a new concept
of industry analysis called ‘the value net’, where they stated that the industry is affected by four
types of players—customers, suppliers, competitors and complementors. The purpose of this
paper is the application of the Structure-Conduct-Performance (SCP) Model to the analysis of
an industry and the Indian Steel Industry has been taken up as an example.
Steel Industry in India is today going through a high demand phase. But, in mid-1990s, steel
industry was facing a crisis because of low demand and poor prices. However, in the last couple
of years, due to increased demand of steel from China and also increased investment of governmentin infrastructure (The Golden Quadrilateral etc.) has resulted in a boom in steel demand. The SCP
Model helps to break down the industry into structural and conduct factors and thereby evolve
a relationship between them so that better understandings of the factors are evolved. |