At all levels of experience, Hemingway brings into focus the finite
individual pitted against heavy nerve-racking odds. To brand him as a
lover of sensation, therefore, would be fallacious in the light of
specific observations that he makes about his own position and that of his
characters in his fictional works. When Cowley and Lillian Ross misinterpreted his
love for sensation, he felt that they had failed to know the truth about him. Even
his literary ideal, wherein he wished to present a sequence of motion and
fact, classifies him as a votary of truth. His love for sensation, therefore, extends
its scope beyond the immediate pleasure and belongs to a larger area of
exploration, his continuous search for the ultimate truth. Sensations form only one of
the steps to the temple of Moneta, and consequently, in their search for reality,
his people become aware of a higher plane where the destiny of man
becomes their vital concern. Along with their zest for the intensity of experience,
they contemplate human aspirations and their doom, their validity
and competence in the cosmic order. Hemingway, therefore, is rather a
committed artist, although the grounds of commitment are entirely moral and aesthetic.
Hemingway does not wallow in mere sensations; he goes beyond their
gratification and examines the fundamental reality of human experience. He finds it
entailing infinite suffering and wishes to project this vision in his works of art. His
tragic sense, therefore, becomes `the weightiest factor in his
craft' (Moloney, 1951,
p. 185). A tragedy implies abundant faith in life, its values of love, and
the potentialities of man to perform wondrous deeds. A nihilist fails to portray such
a vision, as life for him is ugly and sordid in all its manifestations. A largeness
of spirit and a comprehensiveness of destiny with a fundamental belief that life
is worth living are the basic requisites of tragedy, its greatest fruit being
self-knowledge through suffering. A tragedy does not produce gloom or depression but
a sense of exultation, and "is an affirmation of faith in life, a declaration that even
if God is not in His Heaven, then at least Man is in his
world" (Krutch, 1929, p. 125). Man is shorn of his unique stature in a universe where God plays the central
role and the significance of human endeavor is thereby belittled. For a triumph
over misfortune, man has to depend on his personal moral resources than on
the invocation of supernatural blessings. The "sturdy soul of the tragic author
seizes upon suffering and uses it only as a means by which joy may be wrung out
of existence" (Krutch, 1929, p. 126). |