In both Briar Rose (1992) and The
Devil's Arithmetic (1988), Jane Yolen tells the
stories of the Holocaust, even as the stories raise questions
regarding the nature of heroism and what it means to
be a victim. Most children's literature dealing with
the Holocaust is predicated on the identity of the victim
as Jew (see Johanna Reiss's The Upstairs Room,
1972; Doris Orgel's The Devil in Vienna, 1988;
and Lois Lowry's Number the Stars, 1989, among
others), the consequent atrocity—which is usually
not dwelt upon in graphic detail—its associated
trauma, the struggle for survival, and the necessity
to remember. Yolen uses similar storytelling techniques
but moves it one step forward. Her victims are not always
Jews (thus there is the gay victim of Nazi persecution
in Briar Rose), and the primary focus is not
necessarily on the struggle for survival in Nazi-controlled
territory (though both tales have Nazi camps at the center);
rather at the core are other related issues: how identities—both
individual and familial—may be shaped, reshaped
and reinvented as a consequence of having survived concentration
camps, and how remembering and forgetting are not imperatives
but choices each individual comes to via circuitous and
tortuous routes. The survivors' act of remembering the
Nazi camps shapes and is shaped by the ways in which
they live now and how they perceive their former life
in the camp.
The modes of remembering by survivors
of the Nazi camps are crucial in identity formation. This
is so because these acts of retrieving memory are necessitated,
rejected, and shaped by what their present is—as
Jewish Americans; and the identity of individuals and families
are shaped by how they relate to their survivor parents
and grandparents when such memories are revived. How do
these members reconfigure their families? How do Jewish
Americans respond to their Jewish `core' when they are
told of the camps?
In other words, this paper suggests that the very question of `Jewish American' identity for individuals and families becomes contingent upon how memories of the Holocaust are retrieved through storytelling. The Holocaust in memory and stories is a component of their psychological and social identity. Jane Yolen's work, in particular, situates acts of memory retrieval via stories within such contexts of Jewish American children growing up. |