Prime Minister (PM) Manmohan Singh's visit to Washington, DC in November
2009 was billed as the first state visit of Obama presidency. One of the issues
mentioned in the joint statement issued on November 24 after
their deliberations, speaks about nuclear disarmament. For the ruling Democratic
Party in the US today, as it was during the Clinton presidency (1993-2001), nuclear
non-proliferation and disarmament are dear issues. Hence, the two leaders of the
US and India spoke of their "shared vision of a world free of nuclear weapons
and pledged to work together as leaders of responsible states....". There are other
high sounding commitments like `testing moratorium', commitment to ratify
Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT), negotiate "a multilateral, non-discriminatory
and internationally verifiable fissile material cut-off
treaty."
That helps Obama in creating a noble-soul-image of himself post-facto winning the Nobel prize for peace! But how is it that, with such high-sounding goals in
nuclear arena, the peacenik President did not think of carrying forward the baton of
advocacy of No First Use (NFU) of nuclear weapons from the 1995 Noble Peace
LaureateJoseph Rotblat? It is equally a wonder, how with such a deep commitment to
nuclear disarmament, Indian PM missed an opportunity to convince his American
counterpart to accept Indian commitment to NFU as a first step towards nuclear
disarmament as a part of Rajiv Gandhi's vision of a world free of nuclear weapons?
What is the meaning of NFU? How did it originate? What is its significance?
How did it acquire a global appeal? How did it come into Indian thought process?
Can it really become a first step in nuclear disarmament? These are the issues which
I propose to discuss in the following pages. The US has the dubious distinction
of inventing the atom bomb and also of experimenting with its only use so far
and consequent realization of catastrophic destruction it could bring about.
Hence, Americans were also the first ones in proposing an NFU principle. Republican
Senator Ralph Flanders from Vermont, made the earliest suggestion of NFU of
nuclear weapons. He introduced on June 27, 1949 a resolution in the US Senate
stating that "the atom bomb like biological warfare, wholesale poisoning, is not
properly a military device directed against the armed forces of the enemy, but rather is a
means for the mass murder of civilians." Hence, he called upon the Truman
administration to adopt NFU policy. |