IUP Publications Online
Home About IUP Magazines Journals Books Archives
     
A Guided Tour | Recommend | Links | Subscriber Services | Feedback | Subscribe Online
 
The IUP Journal of Operations Management :
Decision Making for Supplier Selection Using the MOORA Method
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Constructing an appropriate model for supplier selection is an important function to improve capability and competitiveness of the business organizations. Proper selection of the suppliers not only avoids manufacturing delays but also helps saving material cost, leading to increase in the profit margins of the organizations. Thus, supplier selection has become crucial in today’s extremely competitive global environment for any organization to be successful. Availability of a large number of alternative suppliers with dissimilar strengths and weaknesses for different criteria requires a cautious step towards supplier selection. In the recent past, various Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) methods have been successfully employed by the researchers to deal with the supplier selection problems. In this paper, Multi-Objective Optimization on the basis of Ratio Analysis (MOORA) is applied to solve two real-time supplier selection problems. The ranking performance of two extensions of MOORA method, i.e., full multiplicative MOORA method and reference point approach, are also tested for the considered problems. The results obtained using these three methods are observed to be almost similar to those derived by the past researchers.

 
 

Supplier selection is one of the most important components of production and logistics management for many organizations. Suppliers provide materials in raw, semi-finished or finished state to the end-users according to their requirements to meet the organizational goals. For those organizations who spend a high percentage of their sales revenue on parts and material supplies, and whose material costs represent a larger portion of the total cost, savings from supplies is of particular importance. Selecting the right supplier significantly reduces the purchasing cost, improves competitiveness in the market and enhances end-user satisfaction. Apart from cost reduction, organizations should continuously work with the suppliers to remain competitive by reducing product development time, improving product quality and reducing lead time. On the other hand, selecting the wrong suppliers may cause operational and financial problems. Supplier selection is the process by which suppliers are reviewed, evaluated and chosen to become a part of the organization’s supply chain.

For many years, the traditional approach to supplier selection has been to choose suppliers solely on the basis of price. However, as the organizations have learned that price as a single criterion for supplier selection is insufficient, they have turned into more comprehensive Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) techniques. Recently, these criteria have become increasingly complex as environmental, social, political, and customer satisfaction concerns have been added to the traditional factors of quality, delivery, cost and service. Some authors have also identified other criteria, like net price, historical supplier performance, capacity, communication systems and geographic location for supplier selection. All these evaluation criteria involve tradeoffs and are a key issue in the supplier assessment process since they measure the performance of suppliers. For example, one supplier may offer inexpensive components of slightly below average quality, while another supplier may offer higher quality components, with uncertain delivery thus setting up tradeoffs. In addition, the importance of each criterion varies from one purchase to the next and is complicated further by the fact that some criteria are quantitative (price, quality), while others are qualitative (service, flexibility). Thus, a technique is needed that can adjust for the decision maker’s attitude towards the importance of each criterion, and incorporates both qualitative and quantitative factors. The selection process mainly involves evaluation of different alternative suppliers based on different conflicting criteria. This process is essentially considered as an MCDM problem. Hence, an effective and competent supplier selection method is essential to obtain a proper supplier from the available alternative suppliers and it should have the characteristics of comprehensiveness, objectiveness, reliability, flexibility, and finally, it has to be mathematically straightforward.

 
 

Operations Management Journal, Relative Efficiencies of Schools, Data Envelopment Analysis, Government-Aided Schools, Linear Programming Model, Decision-Making Units, Organizational Units, Human Resources, Public Procurement Sectors, Government Schools, Education System.