e-readiness indices are essentially evaluative frameworks used to assess nations
(E-ASEAN Taskforce, 2002). A review of evaluation literature by Madon (2004) found
that evaluation criteria ‘come from the field’ and reflect the felt needs and priorities
of the users of the project rather than predefined objective criteria. However, the
combined effort of the subjective and objective criteria may be more appropriate
to measure the e-readiness of a nation which is at a developing stage.
Realizing the importance of e-readiness measurement and its implications for
the economic growth of a nation, many governmental and world organizations
have created their own instruments either in the form of self-assessment tools or
surveys. The most prominent of these institutions are the World Bank (World
Development Indicators, 2001; Knowledge Assessment Matrix, 2002; and Statistical
Information Management Analysis Database Ltd., 2002), McConnell (WITSA, 2000;
and 2001), Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU, 2009), ASEAN (2002), Asia Pacific
Economic Cooperation (APEC, 2000), MOSAIC (2000), and Computer Systems Policy
Projects (CSPP, 1998). Even though they set out to measure, presumably, the
same e-readiness index, they share little commonality in terms of the standards
they use. For example, APEC and Center for International Development (CID)
considered only macroeconomic factors and digital infrastructure in estimating e-readiness, whereas MOSAIC includes knowledgeable citizens as an e-readiness
measure. CSPP has the same number of factors as MOSAIC, namely, three, but
they only share one common factor, macroeconomy with CSPP using two new factors
called competitiveness and access to skilled workforce. However, McConnell uses
six factors in estimating e-readiness, doubling the number used by ASEAN and
CSPP, and tripling those of APEC and CID. The World Bank and EIU propose the
largest inventory of factors, namely, seven, used as an instrument in evaluating ereadiness
but they are not the same; World Bank uses a factor called culture and
EIU uses a factor called cost of living and pricing, each of which is not shared by
the other organization.
|