The IUP Journal of Accounting Research and Audit Practices:
A Comparative Study of Segment Reporting Under AS-17 and IFRS 8: Empirical Evidence from India
Article Details
Pub. Date
:
Jan,
2016
Product Name
:
The IUP Journal of Accounting Research and Audit Practices
Product Type
:
Article
Product Code
:
IJARAP31601
Author Name
:
D D Bedia and Kshema Patodi
Availability
:
YES
Subject/Domain
:
Finance
Download Format
:
PDF Format
No.
of Pages
:
20
Price
For delivery in electronic
format: Rs. 50;
For delivery through courier (within India): Rs.
50 + Rs. 25 for Shipping & Handling Charges
Download
To download this Article click on the button below:
Abstract
This paper examines the benefits of adopting International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) by Indian entities and further examines the effect of adoption of IFRS on companies’ segment reporting as compared to segment reporting under Indian GAAP (IGAAP). It studies the impact of adoption of IFRS 8 by taking the case of M/s Sify Technologies Ltd., an Indian listed entity and presents a detailed analysis of differences in the segment disclosures data under the new standard IFRS 8 vis-ŕ-vis the Indian Accounting Standard, AS-17. It is observed from the study that there are certain marked deviations in the segment profit and loss as disclosed by the financial statements of M/s Sify Technologies Ltd. as reported under IGAAP and those reported under IFRS. The major difference between the two reporting is the information given and the presentation requirement. Further, under IFRS 8, the disclosure requirements related to geographical segments are significantly reduced or in most of the cases completely lost, which is a major concern to stakeholders. Further, there will be lack of comparability of segment information between companies as IFRS provides discretion to the Chief Operating Decision Maker to choose what to disclose and the manner in which the information can be disclosed.
Description
The era of ‘globalization’ has not left the capital markets and the financial markets around
the world untouched and therefore comparison between firms is crucial for investors and
stakeholders around the world to make vital and necessary decisions. The common tool
used by them to take such decision is accounting or financial information. The investors
make use of this information as one of the most important inputs or sometimes the sole
input in their decision-making process to decide whether to invest or not in the securities of
a particular firm. The differences in financial reporting requirements and frameworks across
nations create complications and inconsistent treatment for the companies that are globally
active in preparing, consolidating and auditing the financial statements. This heterogeneity
also renders it impossible to compare financial information of companies from different countries across the world. The differences in accounting standards create confusion for
users of financial statements which leads to inefficiency in capital markets across the world.
It also increases the cost of providing supplementary information so as to make the financial
statements comparable. This globalization of capital markets and increasing complexity of
business transactions call for a single set of high-quality accounting standards. Throughout
the world, the bodies responsible for setting accounting standards in different nations are
exploring ways to eliminate differences in accounting information, thereby creating uniform
standards for preparation of the accounting information so that the financial statements from
anywhere in the world can be easily read and understood by the business and financial
communities. International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) are accounting rules which
are applied while preparing the balance sheet and income statement of a company and are
issued by the International Accounting Standard Board (IASB). IFRS is becoming the global
standard for the preparation of public company financial statements. Convergence with IFRS
has gained momentum in recent years and the accounting bodies all over the world have
realized that the adoption of the IFRS would enable the world to speak the same accounting
language which can be understood by all.
Keywords
Accounting Research and Audit Practices, Comparative Study, Segment Reporting, Empirical Evidence, International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) , Indian GAAP (IGAAP), International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), India.