Negative stereotypes about Islam, the Middle East and Muslim women
have, for long, been perpetuated by the west with a view to legitimizing colonial
occupations and imperialist interventions. This negative stereotyping has intensified
in the post-9/11 atmosphere of mounting Islamophobia. Fictional works, travel
accounts and films proliferate on the `brutal oppression' of women in the Middle
Eastern nations of Saudi Arabia, Iran, Jordan and Afghanistan. The oppression
of women being characteristic of most patriarchal societies, the vicious politics
behind the monolithic depiction of Middle Eastern Muslim women as hapless victims
of Islamic fundamentalism, awaiting the mediation of the `enlightened' west
for their liberation, has to be exposed and critiqued.
Not only writers from the west, but western-based indigenous writers also deplore
the treatment of women in Muslim countries, as if there is a singularity and
homogeneity about their position that makes them quite different from their
`liberated' sisters in the west. The critical gaze on these women makes them
`othered', and fundamentally different, with different problems from those of
women in general. The reality is that "although Arab women, like their
Western sisters, are victimized by male chauvinism and prejudice, they are by
no means as subjugated or oppressed as most Western popular literature would
indicate" (Terry, 1985, p. 26). Chandra Talpade Mohanty remarks that colonization
implies a political suppression of the heterogeneity of the subject(s) in question
(2003, p. 49). The stereotypical representations of Middle Eastern women not
only erase the social, cultural and political diversity of the region, but also
divest the `victimized' women of agency. It is this production of a body of
knowledge, privileging the west as the norm or referent, and demonizing the
orient as an inferior, infantile `Other', that Edward Said has termed `Orientalist'
in his seminal work Orientalism. New Orientalist Narratives
The post-9/11 world has witnessed a massive marketing of stereotyped literary
productions in the 19th century orientalist mode. Fatemeh Keshavarz, an Iranian writer, calls
these types of writing `New Orientalist'. She writes |