When William Dalrymple published In Xanadu: A Quest at the age of 22 and
won the Scottish Arts Council's Spring Book Award in 1990, Alan Franks of The Times, London, hailed the book as `a splendid piece of British
eccentricity.' Dervula Murphy, herself a recognized travel writer, thought that the work brought in
an admirable combination of `history, danger, humor, architecture, people, hardship,
politics, while Eastern Daily
Press reported that `it was rich in esoteric knowledge and a
sense of the ridiculous'.
By now Dalrymple has acquired a somewhat iconic status in the subcontinent as
a travel writer and a cultural historian. He is mentioned in the same breath as other
venerables such as Mark Tully. It may thus be worthwhile to look at his debut travel text In Xanadu. The intention clearly is not to do a post-colonial reading of the derivative kind through
the binary, Manichean tropes, but to see how we can unpack the leading thematics,
namely quest, hybridity and counter-memory that seem to constitute the substance of this
interesting narrative. I use the term "counter-memory" as a working definition as the
experience, both cultural and metaphysical that challenges the dominant memories, crucial to the
self-definition of individuals and civilizations.
Dalrymple positions himself on the recognizable terrain of the western travel
text. There is a Mission into the unknown and there is the Man, on an expedition to the
exotic East, journeying from Jerusalem to the fabled palace of Kubla Khan, Xanadu, in the
far East. Instead of the customary female companion: vulnerable, chaste and sexually
loyal to the protagonist, there is here the one time lover, the feminine Louisa and her
substitute, the athletic Laura, both of whom share the hero's mission but not his bed. There is
irony, and self-deprecatory humor, an attempt to see eccentricity and amusement all around
as indeed self-reflexively within oneself. However, despite the self parody, the book
seems to be trapped by the overall colonial grid and tapestry. The powerful sweep of the
western male gaze and the subservience of the colonized subject are part of the larger
hermeneutic. Dalrymple's quest to retrace the footsteps of the Venetian brothers, Marco and
Nicolo Polo, replicates the journey of Alexander the Great and other
adventurers/buccaneers/ travelers and assorted free booters. |