There are many empirical studies on leadership; however, few have been
concerned with the impact of cultural influence on leadership. In the Handbook of Leadership: Theory, Research and Managerial
Applications compiled by Bass and Stodgill and
there is an important discussion regarding the globalization of many organizations and
the increase of interdependencies of nations that makes the understanding of culture
and its influence on leadership increasingly important.
The field of leadership and cultural studies is abundant in academic, corporate,
and research institute literature. In his work, "A Case for Comparing Apples with
Oranges: International Differences in Values", Hofstede explains that to compare nations
one needs theoretical justification and framework. The question then raised is, whether
the phenomenon that is studied is functionally equal. Hofstede insists that any
comparison of values and attitudes across nations is in some way a comparison of apples to
oranges. It is a fruitless effort, Hofstede remarks, without the proper `fruitology'. The
cultural attitudes, belief systems and values define the leader's behavior as well as those
who follow. Therefore, leadership changes across cultures emphasizing that there
are particular traits that label a leader depending on the region or society. One more
concept to consider is the cultural programming within an individual that has to be
examined carefully when reviewing leadership effectiveness. Hofstede's, Cultures and Organizations: Software of the
Mind explains that every person carries within
himself or herself patterns of thinking, feeling and potential acting which was learnt
through a lifetime of experiences affecting the outcome or result of that person's leadership
style. In this article, two major works will be discussed briefly regarding leadership
cultures: Hofstede's cultural dimensions and the Global Leadership and Organizational
Behavioral Effectiveness (GLOBE) research project on nine cultural dimensions. The work
of Hofstede explained the influence of culture in the leadership processes through a
series of cultural dimensions. These include, power distance, masculinity,
collectivism, uncertainty avoidance and long term versus short-term orientation. Three of
these dimensions in Hofstede's work are defined here: |