This issue carries
papers which are a mix of quantitative and qualitative research
work on Corporate Governance (CG).
The
need for CG mechanisms arises as the managers violate the
ethical norms in fulfilling their responsibilities towards
stakeholders, particularly the shareholders. Religion is the
most important source of ethical norms in any society. On
the other hand, love of money is the characteristic which
motivates the managers to violate the ethical norms. The first
paper "Is the Love of Money Universal Amongst Aspiring
Malaysian Managers?", by Quah Chun Hoo, Wong Si-Maan
and Joshua Ignatius, touches this core issue of `love of money'
which has resulted in the need for CG mechanism in the modern
corporations. The authors analyze the influence of the `love
of money' and `religiosity' on the Machiavellian orientations
of future managers of Malaysia, based on the data collected
from undergraduate business students. They measure the `love
of money', Machiavellianism and `religiosity' with instruments
developed in earlier research works and use regression analysis
and t-tests to understand the three way relationship.
Their study finds that there exists a positive relationship
between `love of money' and Machiavellianism among the Malaysian
undergraduate business students. However, the relationship
between `religiosity' and Machiavellianism is not significant
against a prior expectation of a negative relationship. Though
the relationship is not significant, the finding is significant
as it corroborates the theory that major religions have lost
their influence over many aspects of one's life because of
the increasing materialism of the modern societies.
Managers,
not being ethical in fulfilling their responsibilities, gave
birth to CG and regulatory mechanisms. The second paper "Board
Characteristics that Promote Effective Governance: A Perspective
on Trinidad and Tobago and Jamaica", by Rolph N S Balgobin,
surveys the literature on the emergence of CG and its history.
Given the fact that the board is the most visible face of
internal CG mechanism in the modern corporations, the study
leads itself into an analysis of board characteristics. The
author explains the board characteristics which promote effective
governance, using examples from 47 companies which are listed
on the stock exchanges of Trinidad and Tobago and Jamaica.
In the process, the author studies the level of adherence
with internationally accepted CG standards by these 47 Trinidad
and Tobago and Jamaican companies. The findings seem to be
giving mixed results with compliance on some parameters and
disparities in some other.
Though
CG became a serious subject for both research and practice,
it shot into prominence after the Enron Scam in 2001. Many
countries, including India, have amended their CG regulatory
systems to avoid scams like Enron, happening in their economies.
The third paper "Strategic Corporate Governance: Looking
Beyond Regulations", by Satheesh Kumar T N analyzes the
CG practices of 30 top business firms in India which are a
part of the Sensex, the prominent index of Bombay Stock Exchange.
The author looks into the substance of CG practices rather
than form, based on certain selective parameters. The findings
suggest that the blue-chip Indian business firms and groups
still have some way to go in following the CG norms in full
spirit. The author further argues that focusing on CG practices
will also help the firms strategically.
Not
that, everything is bad with Indian blue-chip firms. The last
paper "Corporate Governance and Corporate Social Responsibility
: The Case of Three Indian Private Companies", by T N
Rama Kumar on three prominent Indian firms, namely ITC Ltd.,
Reliance Industries Ltd. and Infosys Technologies Ltd., suggests
that it is the other way round. The paper compares these three
firms on four selective CG parameters`Approach to CG', `Governance
Structure and Practices', `Board Committees', and `Corporate
Social Responsibility Practices'. The study finds that these
firms indeed follow good CG both in form and substance.
-
S Subramanian
Consulting Editor
|