Before touching upon the main subject we would discuss the rationale behind,
why Value-Added Tax (VAT) was brought in first place to replace Sales Tax.
Commercial Tax on sales, which was collected before the introduction of VAT,
itself was a good, robust, well-designed legislature evolved over a period of time for
collections of fair share of revenue on sales. However to get most out of a system, it is
much dependent upon how it’s being implemented. In our country the level of corruption
is very high and overshadows everything else. Thus, significant amount of sales have
never been reported and governments have failed to correct lapses. It was a nexus
between a corrupt department and the bad blood of the business community, which
flourished at the cost of a good guy in trade. Thus over a period of time after all its
attempts, the government realized that it was just not possible to correct the system in
its present form. In the backdrop of this the legislature came up with the idea to introduce
a new system where the burden of it would fall on the shoulders of subjects who are
liable to tax. Sales Tax has been scrapped. Single-point tax is the best system that fits on
the canon of a good tax system in terms of economic efficiency, administrative simplicity,
transparency and flexibility. Moreover, in the earlier system many states like
Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and West Bengalwere practicing input tax credit in some
form or the other.
One can understand this by a simple example, say, in a school there are students
who have similarity in background and other resources but the students who are keen
about their studies, do perform better than others. The success of any legislature would
depend much on its implementation beside its form and content. It can be highlighted
and seen that a student having modest resources, from an ordinary background and
from a general school put outstanding performance leaving many other students having
resources, studying in big schools, as later ones are modest in using resources at their
disposal. In the similar way, good legislature if implemented in full thrust could producethe desired results than excellent legislature
being poorly implemented.
|