Well-known management consultants
and authors have often tried to simplify competitive strategy by
suggesting that winning strategies need to be
focused either on customer value or on costs.
Such a premise is false and potentially dangerous.
Successful strategies must simultaneously balance both customer value and
costs. Managers can achieve strategic success by focusing on customer value added -
an objective that combines both customer value and cost.
Customer value added for a unit of a product or service is the difference between
the perceived value and cost per unit (Exhibit I). Perceived value is the maximum
a customer will pay for the product or service. Perceived value is not price - it is the
ceiling on the price of the product or service.
Cost per unit is variable cost per unit, not
average price per unit. Average price can distort decisions by masking the incremental
profit for a product or service.
Customer value added (CVA®) is the net value per unit that an
organization provides to the society - as perceived
by members of that society. If CVA is high, then an organization is adding
substantial value to society because perceived
value exceeds costs. However, if CVA is low, then an organization is not adding
substantial value to society but rather adding only
a small amount in excess of their costs. At the extreme, if CVA is negative,
an organization is destroying value to society since the value of their outputs is then
less than the cost of their inputs. When CVA is negative, in a free market, an
organization will cease to exist. |